CONFIRMED
On 21 November 2023, the UK’s Competition Appeal Tribunal refused Sony’s application to strike out a roughly £2 billion ($2.6 billion) class action accusing it of abusing a dominant position over PlayStation Store prices, and certified the claim to proceed on an opt-out basis. Push Square reports that the tribunal concluded Sony did not have a monopoly in digital games and that the claim failed. For PS5 players in the UK, that means no payout from this case, and no court-ordered shake-up of how digital games are sold on PlayStation.
What we know
The case was brought as an opt-out collective action on behalf of UK PlayStation users. An opt-out claim works on behalf of a whole group of eligible consumers by default, so individual players did not need to sign up to be covered by it.
According to Reuters, the claim sought damages estimated at approximately £1.97 billion. It covered UK consumers who bought digital PlayStation games or add-on content through the PlayStation Store during the relevant period. That puts DLC, expansions and other add-ons in scope alongside full digital game purchases.
The core allegation was that Sony’s control of digital game sales on PlayStation led to excessive prices. Those were the claimant’s arguments, not established facts. No finding has been made that Sony actually overcharged anyone, and this ruling does not change that.
Sony pushed back hard. Reuters reports that the company argued it faced competition from other platforms, and that its PlayStation Store terms did not amount to an abuse of a dominant position.
The tribunal sided with Sony on the central question. Push Square reports that it concluded Sony did not have a monopoly in digital games, and that the claim failed as a result.
That is the key point. The case was framed as an abuse of a dominant position. If the tribunal does not accept that Sony held that kind of market power in digital games, the rest of the claim struggles to stand.
What we don’t know yet
There are some obvious gaps in what has been reported so far.
We don’t know whether the claimant side plans to challenge the decision. The reporting covered here says nothing about an appeal, so treat that as an open question rather than something that is or isn’t happening.
We also don’t have the tribunal’s full reasoning in front of us. Push Square’s report covers the headline conclusions, no monopoly and a failed claim, but how the tribunal weighed specific evidence on pricing, store terms or competing platforms isn’t part of the facts available here.
Sony’s response to the ruling hasn’t been reported either. There is no word on whether the company sees this as a reason to keep its store setup exactly as it is, or whether any changes were already planned regardless of the case.
Finally, nothing in the reporting addresses PlayStation Store prices going forward. There is no announced price change, up or down, connected to this outcome.
What it means
For UK players who bought digital games or add-ons on PlayStation during the period covered, the practical takeaway is simple: this case won’t be putting money back in your pocket. The roughly £1.97 billion in damages Reuters described was the claimant’s estimated figure, not an established award, and the tribunal’s November 2023 certification of the claim did not establish liability or create a compensation fund.
For PlayStation Store pricing, the ruling keeps the status quo in place. The tribunal was the venue where Sony’s store terms were being tested against competition law, and Push Square reports the challenge did not succeed. That leaves Sony free to run its digital storefront the way it already does, at least as far as this case is concerned.
It also gives Sony a useful precedent in the UK. The company’s argument, as Reuters reports it, was that PlayStation competes with other platforms. The tribunal’s finding that Sony did not have a monopoly in digital games lines up with that position. Any future challenge built on the idea that Sony dominates digital game sales on its own console would now have this decision to deal with.
The ruling doesn’t settle every question about digital game policy, though. It answers whether this particular claim proved abuse of a dominant position, and the answer was no. It isn’t a verdict that PlayStation Store prices are fair or good value, and it isn’t a finding that prices were excessive either. Players who feel digital games cost too much on PS5 haven’t been told by a court that they’re wrong; they’ve been told this legal route didn’t work.
For the wider industry, the case is worth watching as a signal. Large opt-out claims over digital storefronts are a big-money bet for claimant groups, and a high-profile loss like this one shows how much rides on proving market dominance up front. Whether that changes appetite for similar actions remains to be seen, and nothing in the reporting so far points either way.
For now, PS5 players can expect business as usual on the PlayStation Store: same storefront, same pricing approach, and no court-ordered changes coming out of this case. If an appeal or a fuller breakdown of the tribunal’s reasoning emerges, that is where the next real development would come from.
About this piece
- Fact-checked by Harriet Vance before publication.
- Published





